Google Calendar or Airset?
Tuesday, July 25th, 2006We can finally synch Google Calendar with Palm and Outlook. http://www.companionlink.com/clgoogle.html
But Airset does that for free, plus you can pay them to synch to your mobile phone over the phone company’s network.
Will Google want to use the Big 4’s networks for that, or will they focus only on synching over the internet (and push for more ubiquitous wifi?)
hmmm, Google innovates consistently, but the Big 4 mobile phone companies stifle innovate products and services at the drop of a hat. My guess is that part of the 4 will cooperate with Google to let users synch Google calendar and part of the 4 will want to create their own calendar app, and charge for it monthly.
Of course, how good does Google Calendar look and respond if I try to view it with a mobile phone web browser?
Hmmm, scatch all this. Somebody already made a mobile phone syncher for free using Java:
http://www.gcalsync.com/
But it is not polished.
Security?
If a business is going to move confidential data over the mobile phone network, then it needs to be securely.
Interesting: If I switch either calendar manually to https on a normal computer browser, they both work fine. However, I don’t see a preference that will force secure viewing each time upon a secure login.
Todo: Check for secure synching and viewing over the phone network as well.
So, I need to start synching both of these to both Outlook and my phone: Airset and Google Calendar.
Costs:
Airset.
Synching Palm and Outlook: Free
Synch over mobile phone:
“AirSet Mobile is a subscription service, available through Verizon at a price of $6.49 per month. Airtime charges are incurred only while synchronizing, which typically takes 30 seconds or so, resulting in 1 minute of airtime utilization. ”
Cost with non Verizon Java enabled phones?
Google:
Synching Palm and Outlook: $30 per user, but some known bugs
Synch over mobile phone: Free with Java J2ME enabled phones, but buggy.
Conclusion:
I lean towards Airset, depending on how they work out the J2ME client. They say it will be a monthly recurring charge. Which seems fine since most of our office users would be using only the Outlook, Palm synching for free. That makes it cheaper than Google option. Plus, Airset is committed to developing the synchronization software. Since Google is not pursuing professional development of synchronization, I would give Airset the edge.
note: This all changes if Google releases professional synchronization. However, synch is such a dangerous function because it touches ALL THE DATA for a user. And bad synch’s can destroy every single bit of data for a user. I think I want a dedicated team getting paid to make sure synch does not ever lose a client’s data. Airset.